AGREED RESOLUTION: Orange County Domestic Violence Case Involving Wife of Former Lawrence County Judge Enters Pretrial Diversion
An out-of-county felony domestic violence case involving a prominent Lawrence County political figure’s family has reached an agreed resolution in the Orange County court system.
Candy Robbins, 65, of Bedford—wife of retired Lawrence County Superior Court Judge Michael Robbins—has entered into a formal Pretrial Diversion Agreement to resolve multiple criminal counts stemming from a December 2025 arrest.
Because of the clear judicial conflict of interest that would arise from her ties within the Lawrence County courthouse, the case was investigated, filed, and decided entirely in Orange Superior Court.
The Incident and Initial Arrest
The case began on December 15, 2025, when the Orange County Prosecutor's Office filed a two-count criminal information ledger following an investigation into a domestic dispute.
The State charged Robbins with:
- Domestic Battery Committed in the Presence of a Child Less Than 16 Years Old (Level 6 Felony)
- Interference with the Reporting of a Crime (Class A Misdemeanor)
Following the filing, Orange Superior Court Judge Debra S. Andry found probable cause, issued an arrest warrant, and set a $2,000 cash bond.
The Legal Defense and Resolution
Robbins is represented in this matter by retained attorney J. Scott Callahan of Bedford.
Rather than proceeding to trial, the parties reached an agreed resolution on May 18, 2026, when Lead Orange County Prosecutor Jessica Anne Bansbach and the defense submitted a signed Pretrial Diversion Agreement. Under a diversion, the charges are held under advisement. If Robbins completes all court-mandated counseling and remains in full compliance with the law for a specified period, the State will permanently dismiss the case.
Public Records Access
To maintain absolute transparency, we are providing the official case details so our followers can view the state's certified ledger directly:
- Court: Orange Superior Court
- Case Number: 59D01-2512-F6-000640
- Defendant: Candy Robbins
- Defense Attorney: J. Scott Callahan
Written by
Read next
Police Log 06/14/2026
Police Log: June 13 – 14, 2026 📍 Bedford Police & Lawrence County Sheriff's Departments The following report covers local public safety activity from the past 24 hours. All individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Notable Arrests * 🚔 Michele Spotts (57), Bedford: John Williams Blvd & State Road 37 NB N – Arrested by Bedford Police at 10:53 PM on June 12 for Operating a Vehicle While Intoxicated (OWI), OWI with Endangerment, Resisting Law Enforcement, and DPaying More to Keep Less: How Lawrence County's Public Safety Budget Leaves Deputies—and Taxpayers—Behind
We have looked into the Lawrence County’s public safety finances reveals a costly paradox: local taxpayers have spent over $1.5 million over the past eight years funding a "revolving door" of law enforcement training, while deputy compensation ranks near the bottom of Indiana. Despite holding average property tax capacity and a moderate population, Lawrence County is effectively serving as a free training ground for higher-paying police departments in surrounding counties. The Numbers at a Gl
EXCLUSIVE: Former Employee Released by City of Mitchell After Nearly 18 Years of Service; Questions Raised Over Budget Priorities and Speech Rights
MITCHELL — New documentation and audio recordings obtained by Lawrence County Watchdog provide insight into the recent termination of a long-term Mitchell city worker, highlighting growing tensions over municipal speech, public access, and departmental funding. Wayne Coble—who served nearly 10 years with the Mitchell Volunteer Fire Department and roughly 8 years with the City Water and Sewer Department—was officially served a Letter of Dismissal on August 21, 2026, signed directly by Mayor Don
🏛️ LAWRENCE COUNTY COUNCIL PREVIEW: Sheriff Restructuring, Prosecutor Salary Changes, and Library Bond Headline Busy Agenda 🏛️
The Lawrence County Council will convene for its upcoming regular session tomorrow, Tuesday, August 25, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. in the Lawrence County Courthouse. Council members face a packed agenda featuring department restructurings, salary requests, multiple personnel hiring approvals, and local funding initiatives. The meeting will open with the Pledge of Allegiance, followed by the approval of minutes from the July 14, 2026 special meeting and the July 28, 2026 regular session. Key Agenda It
Police Log 08/29/2026 - 08/31/2026
Bedford Police Department 12-Hour Shift Trial & Weekend Police Logs The Bedford Police Department has officially initiated a 90-day trial schedule on weekends, moving from traditional 8-hour shift rotations to 12-hour operational blocks. Below is an in-depth comparative breakdown of the shift structural changes, paired with the complete public safety logs for both the Bedford Police Department and the Lawrence County Sheriff's Department covering August 28 through August 31, 2026. Shift Archi
Indiana Appellate Court Affirms Near-Maximum Sentence for Lawrence County Man
The Court of Appeals of Indiana has upheld an 11-year, 11-month prison sentence for Anthony R. Henson, 39, following his conviction for Level 4 felony unlawful possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon. The ruling, handed down by Judge Margret G. Vaidik on August 24, 2026, rejects Henson’s claim that his sentence—just one month shy of the statutory maximum—was inappropriate. May 2024 Manhunt and Traffic Stop The case stems from an incident on May 31, 2024, when Lawrence County Sheriff
Talon Briem Reaches Plea Deal in January Speedway Gas Station Shooting Case
📍 BEDFORD, IN — The high-profile criminal case against 18-year-old Talon R. Briem, stemming from a January 2026 gas station shooting, is moving toward resolution following a change of plea hearing in Lawrence Superior Court 1. Briem, alongside defense attorney Timothy Sledd, appeared before Judge John M. Plummer III on August 26, 2026, where he formally entered guilty pleas to an amended charging information. ⛽ THE BACKSTORY: January 5 Speedway Shooting Incident The charges against Briem or